A panel of three PPC marketing experts – Greg Fin (Saru North), Kerry Amodio (Refine Labs), and Mencaim ANI (JEXT Group) faced a fundamental question on SMX Next: What is AI making markets better?

The panel discussed the developed role of Artificial Intelligence in Marketing, providing insight into its promises and disadvantages.

Screenshot 2025 02 11 14.50.09

The discussion was fine. While AI excels on the increase in production volume, there are serious concerns about quality.

New PPC Mentality

Finn specifically argued that AI is potentially making marketing worse when used as a complete solution instead of a strategic tool:

  • “Is it capable of producing more items and materials, such things. I would say yes, if the quantity is your guide light, but if it is quality, I would firmly argue that AI is marketing normally and worse.
  • “People really rely on AI that I think I think perhaps a human can be better. And a lot of changes in platforms really lend to make themselves worse.
  • “It actually comes down how we are using it and people who are using it as a strategy, not as a strategy, I think it is making them worse.”

This feeling was echoed by his fellow panelists, who emphasized the importance of thoughtful implementation.

Annie said:

  • “Like a lot of things, it is really how you use it. This makes it very easy to get bad output, I think that is almost very easy.
  • “The more hard work you do on something, the better. So a lot it actually comes down how you use it, but if you are going to use it better, it can improve the abolition. ,

Amodio, agreed with his fellow experts, expressed that AI could make you a more skilled worker:

  • “This can make you a more skilled worker, a more efficient market. This can come up with various strategies for you that you might not have tested on your own.
  • “But it also manages the water. It plays us a game that we are trying to fit our marketing into a box. And this is not always a good thing.
  • “To write a certain amount of copy in a certain amount of copy, to keep a certain amount of property, it can sometimes make us more than quality, and it is the place where it is where it is worse than before to AI Viponist Is making. “

Where Ai Shines

Experts identified several areas where AI displays clear value. Automated bid emerged as a unanimous success story, in which Amodio used “Smart Boli” in 99% of cases.

ANI shared the success he sees with automatic dialect:

  • “When we use a smart bid in the ad platform, the more algorithm bid contrary to the manual dialect.
  • “They are much more advanced than using some of AI tools to create creative property, copy, to write things of that nature.
  • “So, in my experience, this is where it shines right now, but I think there are many people too.”

Amodio said:

  • “I am going to use smart bid for 99% time to be honest.
  • “I have seen that it is good in the scenarios that target the audience, but there are some railings that you need to put to find the right people.
  • “You need to be really hardworking to do a little manual work in that automation and to ensure that you are reaching the right people.
  • “But sometimes you can take those railings down, let it be found for you those conversions – and I have seen it working well.
  • “So for some brands, it is better working than others.”

Finn agreed to the automatic bidding front with his fellow experts, but also touched the performance maximum campaigns – when clearly structured properly with conversion goals, potentially effective, especially in ecommerce settings:

  • “I just agree on the bid's approach, and I think it will be more clear
    ECPC is going away. It has already gone to shopping, least going away for Google advertisements, and also for search advertisements.
  • “I also think in some supporting assets such as using AI to come up with more shorts
    Or vertical videos, help edit some of those things. If we are taking a clip of this [talk]There are many devices that can do and do a lot of work for you.
  • “Some like a PMX, with proper structure, proper conversion set the appropriate game plan, it could dominate the manual and it is just a fact.
  • “I think it's really good in a broad match. I hated a broad match for most parts of my life. I still don't like to say that I like it, but a broad match DSAS, some of those automation and AI strategy can actually pass and be better for you, coverage. ,

General misconception About AI in Marketing

The panel identified several misconceptions.

A primary concern was the wrong belief that AI makes things easier.

Finn reported that installing AI-operated campaigns often requires more work, not less, especially when complex assets and creative requirements are dealt with.

  • “One of the biggest misunderstandings is that this is a solution that makes things easy for AI only. If you feel that this is true, try to set up a PMX campaign that contains pictures, videos, headlines, details etc. This is not easy in the board just because you have AI.
  • “It is different messaging what platforms are giving us the google launch with PMAX and demand genes, they were half-cooked products and they are now getting amazing at the end.
  • “Use your eyes. Use your mind. Use. Examination See what works.
  • “Just because you hear something that does not mean that this is true, and it is actually difficult to get through customers.
  • “I dare you to use the assets that produce Google advertisements – you will be out of a job. Just because you can make things faster. It does not mean that it is very good. .. I want to be the best. I want to keep the best accessories from there, I am one of the best images and I don't think you can reach there with AI alone.

Experts also warned AI as “set it and forget it” as well as a solution. Successful implementation often takes weeks or months of purification, said Amodio said:

  • “I think one of the biggest challenges, or misunderstanding that we have, are people who think that it is going to work immediately and it is well working.
  • “I have seen that it was on a manual bid strategy to do better than one smart campaign, in two weeks, three weeks, a month. It is going to take time.
  • “In addition, it is not just a set-it-furgate-ice approach. You cannot just assume that AI is in your best interest. You really have to set those railings. See your search query report.
  • “Look at the demographics of your audience and keep those exclusion in place and make sure you are reaching the right people because it is not always going out and searching for those right people, especially B2B Where we are working with the lead generation. This can give you a high volume lead, but this does not mean that they are of quality. ,

Creativity and AI: How do you see this difference between AI and creativity?

One of the most compelling discussions focuses at the intersection of AI and creativity. The panelists expressed concern about the potential symmeting of creative materials, in which Amodio exposes the risk of the need to play the game, but also ensures that you are making advertisements that customers deal with pain points:

  • “I'm going back to this same point … Do we really want to play the game that are laying algorithms? Are …
  • “But at the same time, when creative teams focus on pumping high volumes just, they do not focus on quality; They are not focused on the message, they are not focused on aligning ICP and audience and their pain points.
  • “There is a risk of losing that creativity and losing that relationship between the brand and audience.
  • “But between this level that we have to find, we must have all the assets at all the correct sizes for all the right placements. Then we also have to ensure that messaging is equal, which is not saving us because we have a lot of property to make.
  • “Teams have to be really careful about pre-planning and they have to sit with their demand teams or payment media teams, creative teams and talk about all the resources that they make to make them for a given campaign Needed.
  • “Already know, these are all sizes, these are all glasses that we need, and be really hardworking and really careful, especially the budget we want to spend, especially if you go into a video production There are a lot of money spent in expensive long videos.

Which AI solution in platforms will you ever try?

Amodio does not like PMax for B2B:

  • “B2B in the world, I stay away from PMX. I don't think there is a lot of value. I have not really seen it work. I do not think you need to quit control in the B2B world.
  • “I don't believe that the discovered paid should be a brand play. It should actually be a demand capture play where we are running a demo for your product or for signup or you know, to talk on sale And so we are running these high intentions.

Annie does not believe in neutrality:

  • “I am a big fan of absoluteness in marketing. I like to test things. There are things that do not just work in some places. I think it is very difficult for the lead genes to be right like Max.
  • “But for the most part, I try to find a way to test it and see what I can do because we end with pre -perceptions and AI can sometimes surprise you . “

Finn does not rely on “amazing Google update”:

  • “I don't believe anything that Google just releases and says is amazing. Under the street, it can be stunning, but they are building because they go with some stuff.
  • “They are liked, 'Oh product studios have videos.” If you go there, you have to add some logo, some pictures, some texts. This is a thrift store … not a good product. ,
  • “When the PMX came out, I came out with PMIN stickers … because I had a lot of hatred with it.
  • “When it comes out, the gene demands stake.
  • “I wouldn't say that I never use it, but when something is launched and said as this amazing tool, I am just suspicious.”

What's next for AI in PPC?

Use this moment of AI saturation as an opportunity to invest in high quality, custom creative work that stands out of algorithm material.

What are the responsibility to involve AI with responsibility about practical recommendations for the abolition? The panel offered these concrete suggestions:

  • Start with controlled experiments instead of wholesale changes.
  • Use AI Tools for specific tasks such as video editing and initial advertising copy.
  • Maintain strict brand guidelines when using AI for material production.
  • Use Amy Hebden guide – Chat for PPC: 17 strategic signals you can use today.
  • Keep automated recommendations and auto-appli settings closed, especially on advertising platforms.
  • Instead of changing human strategic thinking, focus on using AI to increase.

The panel concluded that while AI represents a powerful set of equipment for modern abolition, lies in success:

  • Thoughtful implementation.
  • Maintaining human monitoring.
  • Using automation to increase strategic thinking (not replaced).

This era of growing automation can actually be the perfect time to distinguish through high quality, human-guided creative work, as Finn has summarized.

See: Have you switched to the new PPC mindset? + Overtime live Q&A

Here SMX is next to full panel discussion:



Source link